Joe Fattorini's Substack

Joe Fattorini's Substack

"By skeptics. For haters."

If we're serious about sustainability we need a conference of the non-believers.

Joe Fattorini's avatar
Joe Fattorini
Aug 28, 2026
∙ Paid

“Worrying is less work than doing something to fix the worry. This is especially true if we’re careful to pick the biggest possible problems to worry about. Everybody wants to save the earth; nobody wants to help Mom do the dishes.”

― P.J. O’Rourke, All the Trouble in the World

I’ve been invited to a conference on wine and sustainability. I’m not going to go. Obviously. Oh the earnestness. The virtue. The “we’re on the right side of history” of it all.

But more importantly, I don’t believe it will make any difference. Sustainability conferences are full of good, kind people who preach to the converted. But then so is Methodism, which is predicted to die out by 2040. About the same time as the Northern White Rhinoceros.

To really to change the world-of-wine-sustainability we need skeptics capable of bringing along haters. Which is why I want to put together a sustainability conference called “By Skeptics, for haters”. And my conference programme would look very different.

The Sustainability Paradox

Once everyone has signed in and got their mug of Rainforest Alliance coffee, the first session will tackle the “Sustainability Paradox”: the reality that brands who go hard on sustainability claims have a tendency to underperform commercially. To make matters worse, they even end up making people less likely to behave sustainably.

We know this from a meta-review of 94 studies called “When Sustainability Backfires”. Shoppers just see too many “green” claims on the high street which leads them to switch off. On top of that they see too many cases where companies claim to be “sustainable” but don’t back it up with action. And most damaging of all, for many of us, “sustainable” means “less tasty” or “more expensive”.

Or both.

This is the sort of thing that led a sparkling wine brand to withdraw the “organic” labels on its wine last year. A vivid example of “greenhushing”. They didn’t change how they made it. (It was still organic). They just stopped telling people. And they’re not alone. Companies are discovering there’s a silent majority of skeptical shoppers with a purchasing power that far outweighs the sort of true believers you meet at sustainability conferences. Those companies are also recognising there are millions out there who will tell researchers that they “definitely will” buy sustainable products in surveys, because... well, who wants to be the sort of bastard who tells a researcher that they just wants something cheap and tasty and don’t give a stuff how it came to be that way?

It’s a modern variation of David Ogilvy’s line that “people don't think what they feel, they don't say what they think and they don't do what they say”. But green.

You’re very probably making it worse

After that cheery opener we’ll follow up with a session with the punchy title, “To be honest you’re probably making it worse by banging on about it”.

In an eye-opening session we’ll learn from a behavioural scientist about a thing known as Brehms reactance theory. Which suggests that deep down, people are like deliberately contrary teenagers. Or as Mark Twain put it:

“There is a charm about the forbidden that makes it unspeakably desirable.”

The more sustainability is presented to us as an obligation and moral imperative... the more people react against it. Extraordinarily, this is true even for people who were open to the idea in the first place. Telling people they’re morally deviant for liking heavy bottles or conventionally farmed vines doesn’t dissuade them from choosing those wines. It actually makes them more likely to reach for 900 gram bottle of “Chateau Roundup”. Even if they were open to sustainable wines before.

Big is beautiful (in the world of sustainability)

And there’s going to be time for one more session before lunch. So the haters & skeptics conference will tackle an unpalatable truth: the big winners in a sustainable wine future will be the big boys.

This effect is true of anything that imposes regulatory costs. Like the imposition of GDPR. Multiple studies found that Europe’s GDPR regulations disproportionately benefited larger companies. That was for the simple reason that bigger companies could cope with all the compliance costs better than smaller companies.

I see a wine example of this every time I walk into the Swedish wine monopoly. Systembolaget is proud of the sustainable credentials of the wines in its permanent range. Its goal is to be the world’s most sustainable wine retailer. But it’s not achieving this goal by persuading small, artisanal producers to switch to lighter-weight bottles or to pay for eco-certifications. Small winemakers can’t afford that sort of thing. So they get moved into the temporary assortment with its smaller sales. While the bigger brands who can afford to switch bottle weight or pay for a certificate take over their listings.

This is not an isolated example. It’s a global phenomenon in multiple industries. This is why we see larger firms actively lobbying in favour of stricter regulations. Not because they’re true believers. But because these regulations act as “moats”; costly impositions the big firms can afford but are barriers to entry for everyone else. Don’t believe me? Just look at the sponsor list the next time you see a wine sustainability conference.

They’re not being kind. They’re building a moat.

Compulsion, self-interest, and honesty

By lunch we should all be pretty clear that the usual ideas about how we can save the planet via the medium of sustainable wine choices are largely bunk. So what would work better?

Read on by becoming a paid subscriber.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Joe Fattorini.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Joe Fattorini · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.